A forum for VE lucubration

Monday, October 09, 2006

Timothy Williamson's 'Neo-Tethering' Solution to the Meno problem

The Meno challenges us to figure out what makes knowledge more valuable than mere true belief. This challenge becomes particularly difficult if we are on board with Socrates in thinking that knowledge and true belief are equally practically useful.

Jon Kvanvig (2003) in “The Value of Knowledge and the Pursuit of Understanding” has pointed out the flaws of quite a few attempts to solve the problem. This book is rich and instructive.

One account that he rejects, however, appears more promising than others. This is the account given by Timothy Williamson (2000), which claims that knowledge is more valuable than true belief because of its relative cross-temporal permanence to true belief. That is, Williamson takes it that knowledge is less likely to be undermined by future evidence than is true belief.

Williamson’s account is a probabilistic account, and it appears to hold true in our world, even though (as Kvanvig points out) not all cases of knowledge in our world are more permanent than mere true beliefs. This is because of facts about belief fixation. Some of our beliefs are fixed pragmatically—for example—they are instinctive, and not fixed evidentially. When such beliefs are true but not known, then we have mere true belief that would appear particularly resistant to being undermined, more resistant it is likely than some of our knowledge.

From this, Kvanvig supposes that in some worlds, unlike ours, the majority of beliefs will be fixed pragmatically and non-evidentially; thus, in some worlds, knowledge is less permanent than true belief.

Does such a view undermine Williamson’s claim?

Kvanvig thinks that it does, and he reasons as follows: Because some possible worlds with a preponderance of pragmatic belief fixation would be such that knowledge would be less permanent than mere true belief, then Williamson’s claim is merely a contingent truth, which will hold only in some worlds in which knowledge is more permanent than true belief.

This is bad, he thinks, because “It is simply false that knowledge loses its value in worlds where the environment is less cooperative and where pragmatics play a more significant role in belief fixation.” (2003b p. 17)

I agree with Kvanvig that knowledge doesn’t appear, at least prima facie, like the sort of thing that would lose its value in some worlds. But are we entitled to draw the conclusion that knowledge would lose its value in some worlds from the fact that Williamson’s account would be false in some worlds? I’m not sure we are. It seems like all we can conclude is that, in such worlds (where pragmatics play a significant role in belief fixation), the value of knowledge over true belief in such worlds would not be its permanence. Of course, this would still leave open the possibility that knowledge could be valuable (and more valuable than true belief) for different reasons in such worlds. And so, it doesn't seem like we must reach the conclusion that knowledge must lose its value in such worlds (which Kvanvig seems to take as a reductio to the view).
One would, of course, dismiss my suggestion if they took it that the value conferring property of knowledge must hold across all possible worlds, but I don’t see what that would be so. (For example, in some worlds, winter coats might be eaten for sustenance and be valuable for that reason; in our world, we wear them). Is it obvious that knowledge is so relevantly dissimilar that a world-relative account of value is plausible in the former case and implausible in the latter?
One problem though, I think, for defending Williamson’s view as an response to the Meno problem is that it appears to be making a universal claim, and as Kvanvig shows (through some counterexamples), there are particular examples that undermine a universal claim about knowledge’s permanence.
If Williamson’s goal, though, is to explain why knowledge is more valuable than true belief for us, perhaps he should weaken his view and claim that “knowledge is significantly more likely to be more permanent than is true belief.” Embedding this probability claim within probability claim muddies the notion, but perhaps it is a move in the right direction. I’ll stop rambling now; I’m open for suggestions on this (if you couldn’t already tell)

13 Comments:

Blogger j. adam carter said...

Hi JP, thanks for this.

What reasons are there for granting (4) of your construal of the argument? Kvanvig supports (4) by claiming that denying (4) entails an absurdity, namely, that in some worlds (where pragmatacs play a significant role in belief fixation)knowledge would lose its value. (He gives this argument on p. 17) If denying (4) entailed that, that might well be a good reason to endorse (4); however, as I've argued, I dont' think it is clear that it does. This is because in such pragmatic-belief-fixation worlds, the value of knowledge would be something other than for the reason that it is permament. However, it still seems an open question as to whether knowledge's value is 'lost' (this notion being the force of Kvanvig's reductio against denying (4).

So what I'm wondering is why (4) is to be assumed true. What is so absurd about accepting that knowledge's value over true bleief is a contingent fact?

Perhaps I'm overlooking something obvious here. Hopefully you can help me get clear on it.

Anyway, thanks again for your comment.

Cheers, Adam

3:55 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Local matt cutts is hence growing extensively. No corporate
press release can get such traction unless the name of the
product that you are also a scam. To do this,
search engines are at right now.

Take a look at my web blog; why is search engine optimization important

11:50 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I glued hundreds of them on a mirror frame to
make a web page. Anther key feature of web crawlerLINKPRO is that it
is done with good taste and then they use their full company name.


my blog - search engine optimization miami

4:02 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Whatever our relationship has been www.how to get
a boyfriend in a committed relationship or not. Recklessly, and knowing it was doomed, he continued
his 'highly romantic and thrilling course' with Maeve.



Here is my web-site: best ways to get ex boyfriend back

3:39 PM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet, tiffany and co, burberry outlet, louboutin outlet, louboutin shoes, ray ban sunglasses, michael kors outlet, louis vuitton outlet, oakley sunglasses cheap, coach outlet, chanel handbags, longchamp handbags, louis vuitton, tiffany and co, longchamp handbags, gucci outlet, nike shoes, louis vuitton outlet stores, polo ralph lauren outlet, oakley sunglasses, louis vuitton outlet, christian louboutin shoes, prada handbags, coach factory outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet, burberry outlet, ray ban sunglasses, prada outlet, michael kors outlet, louis vuitton handbags, longchamp outlet, air max, tory burch outlet, coach outlet store online, nike free, kate spade outlet, jordan shoes, louboutin, michael kors outlet, kate spade handbags, michael kors outlet, air max, michael kors outlet, coach purses

1:27 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

ugg, mcm handbags, instyler, insanity workout, ugg australia, reebok outlet, giuseppe zanotti, nfl jerseys, valentino shoes, longchamp, ugg boots, babyliss pro, nike huarache, nike trainers, ghd, hollister, barbour, marc jacobs, north face outlet, bottega veneta, vans shoes, ferragamo shoes, mont blanc, new balance shoes, abercrombie and fitch, ugg pas cher, lululemon outlet, soccer jerseys, p90x, celine handbags, wedding dresses, asics running shoes, birkin bag, abercrombie and fitch, uggs outlet, rolex watches, nike roshe run, soccer shoes, beats by dre, nike roshe, chi flat iron, herve leger, north face jackets, mac cosmetics, jimmy choo outlet

1:32 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

juicy couture outlet, hollister, air max, louboutin, ralph lauren, canada goose jackets, moncler, vans, juicy couture outlet, moncler, timberland boots, moncler, oakley, canada goose, gucci, ugg, rolex watches, baseball bats, canada goose, air max, canada goose, moncler, canada goose uk, karen millen, hollister clothing store, converse shoes, moncler, wedding dresses, louis vuitton, ugg boots, moncler outlet, parajumpers, canada goose, toms shoes, canada goose outlet, montre homme, moncler, supra shoes, canada goose, converse, hollister, ugg, ray ban, lancel, coach outlet store online, iphone 6 cases

1:33 AM

 
Blogger Unknown said...

huangqihang0530rolex watches
tory burch outlet
coach outlet online
nike air max
michael kors bag
ray ban sunglasses
kate spade uk
oakley sunglasses
chanel online shop
oakley sunglasses wholesale
ray ban sunglasses
burberry outlet
ray ban outlet
air max 95
true religion outlet
coach outlet store online
coach outlet store online
pandora charms
michael kors outlet online
michael kors
true religion jeans
gucci outlet
oakley sunglass
tory burch outlet online
ray ban glasses
true religion sale
ralph lauren
michael kors
cheap ray ban sunglasses
oakley sunglasses
coach factory outlet
chanel handbags
gucci uk
toms shoes
coach factory outlet
q

6:22 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

jordan shoes, christian louboutin, uggs outlet, michael kors outlet online, uggs on sale, louis vuitton outlet, louis vuitton outlet, louis vuitton, ray ban sunglasses, replica watches, christian louboutin uk, chanel handbags, michael kors outlet online, uggs outlet, longchamp outlet, nike air max, michael kors outlet, burberry handbags, tiffany and co, polo outlet, nike free, nike air max, ugg boots, oakley sunglasses, ray ban sunglasses, michael kors outlet online, oakley sunglasses, christian louboutin outlet, longchamp outlet, prada handbags, gucci handbags, prada outlet, oakley sunglasses wholesale, michael kors outlet, oakley sunglasses, kate spade outlet, christian louboutin shoes, louis vuitton outlet, tory burch outlet, ugg boots, michael kors outlet online, burberry outlet, cheap oakley sunglasses, louis vuitton, ray ban sunglasses, nike outlet, longchamp outlet

6:53 AM

 
Blogger Shaimaa Elsadek said...

مكافحة حشرات بالرياض
لرش إبادة الحشرات عليك الاستعانة بشركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض فهي شركة متخصصة في رش الحشرات بالمنزل والتخلص منها نهائياً دون رائحة ودون مغادرة المنزل و تستخدم الشركة أقوى المبيدات وأفضل طرق الرش الآمنة علي صحة الأطفال و كبار السن وهي الأولى بدليل الشركات الخاصة بمكافحة الحشرات حيث نقوم بالقضاء علي كافة أنواع الحشرات مثل النمل الأبيض و العثة و البعوض و البق و الفئران والصراصير و تتميز بالمهنية توفر خدمة رش مبيدات الحشرات في داخل الرياض مع الضمان وطاقم العمل يتكون من متخصصين في القضاء النهائي علي الحشرات بأنواعها وأسعار الشركة تعتبر أرخص أسعار لرش الحشرات تواصل معنا الآن يصلك مندوب في الحال

2:10 AM

 
Blogger Shaimaa Elsadek said...

مكافحة النمل الابيض بالرياض
شركة مكافحة النمل الأبيض بالرياض تم تصنيفها بأنها أفضل شركات الإبادة الحشرات ويرجع تصنيف المركز الألماني إبادة الحشرات إلى المركز الأول لاستخدام الأمانة في استخدام مبيدات صحة عامة لا تؤثر علي صحة الإنسان و استخدام أفضل أنواع المبيدات الحشرية في القضاء علي النمل الأبيض و الفئران و الصراصير و البق و النمل و العته و الجرذان و مكافحة النمل بجميع أنواعه مثل النمل المنزلي و النمل الأبيض بأفضل أنواع مبيدات الصحة العامة المستخدمة في مكافحة النمل فنحن أكفأ شركة لمكافحة النمل و معتمدة من وزارة الصحة لمكافحة الحشرات و النمل بدون مغادرة المكان و بدون نقل الأواني بدون مواد سامة لا تتردد بالتواصل معنا.

2:11 AM

 
Blogger Mai said...

ارخص شركات نقل الاثاث
شركات نقل ورفع الاثاث بالونش

7:07 PM

 
Blogger rabab saad said...

شركة تنظيف مجالس بالجبيل


شركة تنظيف فلل بالجبيل

شركة تنظيف شقق بالجبيل

شركة تنظيف خزانات بالجبيل

شركة تنظيف بالجبيل

شركة تنظيف افران بالجبيل

شركة تسليك مجاري بالجبيل

شركة جلي بلاط بجدة

شركة جلي بلاط بمكة

شركة تنظيف مكيفات بمكة

9:49 PM

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home