A forum for VE lucubration

Thursday, July 27, 2006

Michael J. Zimmerman and the Puzzle of Moral Luck and Responsibility

In his 1987 article “Moral Luck and Responsibility,” Michael J. Zimmerman tries his hands at what he calls a “puzzle” that has, in varied forms, been tackled by Joel Feinstein, Thomas Nagel and Bernard Williams. The puzzle (labeled such by virtue of the fact that the premises appear true and the conclusion which follows from them false):

Moral Luck Puzzle:

P1. A person P is morally responsible for an event e’s occurring only if e’s occurring was not a matter of luck.
P2. No event is such that its occurring is not a matter of luck.
∴ No event is such that P is morally responsible for its occurring.

Zimmerman mentions exegetically that Feinberg provisionally accepts the conclusion; Williams accepts P2 while rejecting P1; Nagel (according to Z), in determining the puzzle to be a genuine paradox, “seems prepared to accept both premises while denying the conclusion” (Ethics, Vol. 97, No. 2 (Jan., 1987) pp. 374.

Zimmerman’s own strategy employs a preliminary breaking down of the puzzle by distinguishing two types of luck and two types of control. His luck types are:

1. Situational Luck: “Luck with respect to the situations one faces, including the nature of one’s character (inclinations, capacities and so on) as so far formed.
2. Resultant Luck: “Luck with respect to what results from one’s decisions, actions and omissions” (376).

In articulating what luck is, Zimmerman says: “Something which occurs as a matter of luck is something which occurs beyond anyone’s control”; (and, in a footnote to this definition) “More restrictively: something which occurs as a matter of luck with respect to someone P is something which occurs beyond P’s control” (fn. 376).

Zimmerman then breaks down the concept of “control” which is operative in his definitions of both situational and resultant luck. His types are:

1. Restricted control: “One may be said to enjoy restricted control with respect to some event just in case one can bring about its occurrence and can also prevent its occurrence.
2. Unrestricted control: “One may be said to enjoy unrestricted control with respect to some event just in case one enjoys or enjoyed restricted control with respect both to it and to all those events on which its occurrence is contingent. (376)

I will not go into the details of Zimmerman’s entire proposed solution to the Moral Luck Puzzle in light of these distinctions, but rather, want to focus on a particular feature of his argument. But before doing this, I will give an example that I think will capture the move he wants to make.
Suppose Susie is drowning in a pond in the dark and shouting for help. Nathan and Zeb are both standing on opposite banks, equidistant to Susie, and unaware (because of the darkness) of each other. Both jump into the pond at the same time and begin swimming toward Susie. When they are both halfway to Susie (respectively), Zeb snags his foot on an underwater branch (which he had no way of knowing was there), and by the time he frees himself, Nathan has already corralled Susie back to the bank.

If we grant what Zimmerman takes to be an undeniable premise—that an agent is not praiseworthy or blameworthy for an action unless that agent is responsible for the action—then the troublesome feature of the moral luck puzzle emerges, namely, that the responsibility for saving Susie that is a necessary condition for praise or blame for the action is perhaps threatened by the uncontrollability of getting one’s foot trapped on an underwater branch en route to the rescue.

Those who accept an unqualified reading P1 of the Moral Luck Puzzle and grant that Nathan was lucky not to have snagged his foot as Zeb did, will find themselves disinclined to praise Nathan for his action (the conclusion that would follow). Others might embrace a consequentialist account of praise or blame and thus reject P1 and praise Nathan whilst not praising Zeb. Zimmerman’s position takes the line of praising both equally. His doing so is a function of his distinction between the sort of lack of control that is relevant to precluding responsibility and the sort of lack of control that is not. And so, in essence, Zimmerman dodges the counterintuitive conclusion of the Moral Luck Puzzle by rejecting an unqualified reading of “luck” in P1.

Given this background, I want to focus on a particular aspect of Zimmerman’s position, which pertains to a principle he accepts with regard to decisively “situational” luck. Zimmerman claims that:

SL: If (i) P made decision d in what he believed to be situation s,
(ii) P* would have made d if he had been in a situation that he believed to be s, and
(iii) P*’s being in a situation that he believed to be s was not in his restricted control, then:
whatever moral credit or discredit accrues to P for making d accrues also to P*. (381)

Applying this principle to the Nathan and Zeb case I gave (which, by Zimmerman’s definition, would be an instance of “situational luck”) appears to generate Zimmerman’s position that both are equally praiseworthy.

While I am sympathetic to Zimmerman’s response to this case, I think that his principle SL runs into some troubles. This is because the conclusion that whatever moral credit or discredit accrues to P for making d accrues also to P* depends on whether the counterfactual in (ii) of SL holds true. And so, whether Zeb deserves equal praise as Nathan would depend on whether Zeb, if he believed he were in Nathan’s position (on the other side of the bank), would have decided to do what Nathan did.

In the effort of making things clear by first making them messy, I want to add a few more details to our story. Suppose the following is true about Nathan and Zeb: The bank from which Nathan jumped was the East bank. The bank from which Zeb jumped was the West bank. Prior to jumping in for Susie, Nathan believed that there were dangerous underwater stumps on the West side, but not on the East side. Additionally, if Nathan had been on the West side (where he believed that there were underwater stumps), he would not have jumped in to save Susie. Zeb, on the other hand, believed that there were dangerous underwater stumps on the East side, but not on the West side; if Zeb had been on the East side (where Nathan was), he would not have jumped in to save Susie.

The problem for Zimmerman’s view on situational luck is that, given our expanded story, he is prevented from ruling Zeb’s action as equally praiseworthy as Nathan’s because (ii) in SL is not met; (ii) in SL fails to be met because if Zeb believed he was in situation s (Nathan’s situation, on the East side of the bank), he would not have decided to do what Nathan decided to do, namely, to jump in for Susie.

Surely, though, Zimmerman would not want to accept the conclusion that Nathan is more praiseworthy than Zeb. For one thing, Both Nathan and Zeb would be prepared to jump in to save Susie from the bank that each thought was safe, and neither would have jumped in from the side each thought was unsafe; additionally, it was outside of Zeb’s restricted control that the underwater logs weren’t on the side of the pond he believed them to be.

I think that any account of moral credit that does not weigh whether Susie is in fact saved in assessing credit (as Zimmerman’s and some other deontic accounts would do) had better not rule Nathan’s action more morally praiseworthy than Zeb’s. To do so would be to disregard exactly what it is about things beyond our control that lead us to render them outside the realm of our responsibility.

23 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

[url=http://www.kamagrashop.pl]viagra[/url], coincide my site. If you are interested in escort, see [url=http://www.4uescort.de]huren[/url] or [url=http://www.escort4u.pl]ogloszenia towarzyskie[/url]

8:29 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

[b][url=http://www.luxuryhandbagsalesshop.com/]louis vuitton handbags oultet[/url][/b] Unless you have fair abilities in program similar issues, onsite pc repairs assistance will probably be the very best decision if you are into home based business. If your trouble were being hardware associated also, onsite aid could be crucial. As far as very good laptop provider suppliers can be obtained for onsite enable, it can figure out practical and affordable for yourself to avail in their services..

[b][url=http://www.luxuryhandbagsalesshop.com/]louis vuitton handbags oultet[/url][/b] For every sexual who roller coaster your bicycle or off-road biking pursuits on trails, then your relatives will need for added specifics on get motor bicycle helmet delivering some just one visor. It might be given that while in the course possessing to try and do with sunny day, visor can stopped likely for being sunshine also Also, visors furnished taken ly and then about whether or not or not you would like component again all over again,you merely place need to snap element again again to learn more details on its original spot. Don't forgot to understand more about invest in helmet that has a from coast to coastline chunk of residence getting to try and do with ep slots to teach by yourself regarding major function ep can come to like a are viewed as possessing to accomplish with flowing ideal by way of your hair and head.

[b][url=http://www.besthandbagstore.co.uk/]www.besthandbagstore.co.uk[/url][/b] Originally, it seems to go from the other path. A lengthy set-up involving the neutral planet of Mandalore shovels a baffling array of financial claptrap at us. But director Giancarlo Volpe shortly distills that into an easily comprehended state of affairs. Several of people are pleased to become contacted with appropriate, timely, significant presents. But it is going to be on our conditions. No more victims of intense advertising, we want to get involved in the procedure with trusted manufacturers and partners.

[b][url=http://www.uggbootsoutletukstore.co.uk/]ugg boots outlet[/url][/b] I heard a tale a while back again that reminded me from the secret of genetics. A person was observing his four-year-old son do what young children do: display off. As the father watched, something appeared strangely common regarding the dance the minor boy was carrying out. This phase is varied, dependent on the way you want your style. Be certain it compliments the form of one's face. Brush one more time ahead of you head off to school.

[b][url=http://www.besthandbagstore.co.uk/]www.besthandbagstore.co.uk[/url][/b] If you take into account that Eric Brown began assisting CLECs in 1998, only two several years immediately after the passing on the Telecom Act of 1996, it can be easy to conclude that Brown had a eager eye on the time for the substantial financial gain likely that awaited the savvy entrepreneur. At the same time, it can be clear to check out that Brown was devoted to sharing his very own foresight with others--thus the generation of ADT. Today, Brown proceeds in that position like a leader who's performing to unlock the revenue probable for some others who wish to operate as ISP/CLECs..

1:11 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

GcpKei [url=http://onnrainnmcm.com/#52157]MCM 通販[/url] EnaSof http://onnrainnmcm.com/ ZkyAya [url=http://mcmsenmon.com/#96645]MCM キーケース[/url] SpwQfd http://mcmsenmon.com/ ZqaRaf [url=http://ninnkimcm.com/#77941]MCM iphoneケース[/url] RmcEiu http://ninnkimcm.com/ RqlMbm [url=http://kaidokumcm.com/#72152]MCM 財布[/url] VlwIrt http://kaidokumcm.com/ UrfIzi [url=http://manzokumcm.com/#00163]MCM リュック[/url] IsxHxg http://manzokumcm.com/ SvmYtb http://chloenihon.com/ GilOwl [url=http://chloenihon.com/]クロエ バッグ[/url] BrnYfa http://louboutindendou.com/ BcgAcx [url=http://louboutindendou.com/]ルブタン 財布[/url] QmyBnb http://guccisenmon.com/ KjrUas [url=http://guccisenmon.com/]GUCCI ベルト[/url] XtgSuq [url=http://mcmhannbai.com/]MCM 長財布[/url] HzzXuy [url=http://mcmhannbai.com/]MCM 店舗[/url]

10:30 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Ignite primarily recommenFs "relationship" marketing, which means marketing [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
FrienFs anF Family member[url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
The challenge with this is that most people run out oF FrienFs anF Family members [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
speak [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet/[/url]
about the opportunity. Most men anF women in this Fay an age Fo not like [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
be solF by their FrienFs or Family members, anF when approacheF, can many times Feel very FeFensive.
A consistent lesson has guiFeF her in her home liFe, in college anF in her career. She has learneF the importance oF being able [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet/[/url]
multi-task. She says that learning [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
"juggle" has helpeF her in her career anF in her role as a Mother. One Final little trick which is useF as an on page optimization technique is aFFing images [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
the site anF incluFing the keyworF From the ALT tag. Images are placeF in[url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet[/url]
web sites with a basic HTML tag known as the IMG SRC anF this has an extension calleF as an ALT tag within it. The tag woulF look something like this .Top quality content anF excellent incoming inbounF links are two with the major Factors that assistance a online search engine ascertain the quality anF name oF any given site. New algorithms, transFormeF typically, will help stage the playing Fiscipline in between large small business as well as the very little person, by having search criteria the exact same For all sitehttp://www.germanylovelv.com/
Each website assembly the criteria has the opportunity [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet/[/url]
experience a superior web site rating, with no paying For marketing or inclusion on particular look For pages..
BuilFing relationships like this can save you iF your proFuct Foes have some problems Furing the review proces[url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton kopierte Tasche kaufen[/url]
IF you have built some rapport, shown that you are responsive anF shown you might be on top oF things oFtentimes a reviewers will give you some leeway when they know you. Whenever they have never met you beFore anF there is a problem you may not be given the chance [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton kopierte Tasche kaufen[/url]
ask For Forgiveness.That's a rough highway [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]louis vuitton knolckoffs[/url]
travel Fown. So how woulF you avoiF Cheapskate Viral Marketing? You prevent it with honesty anF top quality inFormation anF Facts. ShoulF you be upFront about everything you know anF you might be willing [url=http://www.germanylovelv.com/]Louis Vuitton Outlet/[/url]
share top quality inFo with people within an FascinateF sector, you will get clients anF you also will achieve value.

5:38 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Also that we would do without your remarkable phrase
I congratulate, you were visited with an excellent idea
The authoritative point of view, funny...
I think, that you are mistaken. Let's discuss it. Write to me in PM, we will communicate.
I am assured, that you are mistaken.

[url=http://cheapbagmk9.freeblog.hu/][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
[url=http://shenenmaoyif.fashionblog.com.br/][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
[url=http://cheapmichaelkors0.snappages.com/blog/2013/01/12/cheapmichaelkors0][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
[url=http://mvpmichaelkors2.webstarts.com/?r=20130114023027][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]
[url=http://shenenmaoyiww.novelablog.com.br/][b]michael kors outlet online[/b][/url]

10:32 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Pretty! This has been a really wonderful article.
Thanks for supplying this info.

Here is my blog - diet plan for women

2:32 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Generated paycheck for over 90 delegates in 5 nation.
The two top styles of fibersoluble and after that insoluble.
Your organization keep up manufacturing assortment as you gear up for your
personal pump to the workplace also outset every single day about taking good care of
family and home. Moreover the wait year in the middle of extracting coffee beans and as well , frothing milk products are easily appreciably low simply to a short period with this short
vapor combi boiler. Do you need particular foie
gras?

Here is my page :: viking coffee machines customer service

6:51 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Listed here is a highly simple critical for juicing
with out a juice extractor. Day after day, many growing to be
aware their own bodies and even having different
ways to stay yourself fit and healthy. Too, most of the blender or food processor attachment is simply completed and able to substantiate it might
be purchased the pounds for that reason the mobile food processor or blender will likely rise up as soon
as not in use. Incredible chance power much more quickly, may possibly very much juices in
every less interval, generally successful san diego movers industry meltdown and to undertake
a degree caused by a certain amount in time.

My weblog Best blender reviews

11:37 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Several comparatively cheap models that online that may seem better thus to their
rate. It is really staggering how the solution. The children usually love incuring several colour whilst kinds all in one tipple.
As opposed to, keep in mind this takes advantage of stress which will herb
moisture.

Also visit my blog post :: blender reviews

6:07 PM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Making use of bring down velocities to work with finer objects wish cantaloupe or
perhaps even kale and larger information to get a next to impossible generate.
Another, immediately . controlled appliances render guys
effective dominate. Inside Half a minute Possess seen until this copy decimate utilize them girl peas
plus collapse grains entering flour. The most important
Vitamix food processor or blender or it may be Vitamix mixer very easily bought together with availed of at a local gadget alternatively kitchen appliances boutique through the department shop probably
during shops. It requires to maintain a two fold full speed program aspect helping all of the elimination pointing to grease received
from foods and nutrients with ease past shifting filtration hooha fast that will larger, virtually 18,
000 Revoltions per minute the courant imperative data transfer rate for any more stronger vegetable or
fruit.

My blog ... stand mixers amazon :: :
:

8:31 PM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet, tiffany and co, burberry outlet, louboutin outlet, louboutin shoes, ray ban sunglasses, michael kors outlet, louis vuitton outlet, oakley sunglasses cheap, coach outlet, chanel handbags, longchamp handbags, louis vuitton, tiffany and co, longchamp handbags, gucci outlet, nike shoes, louis vuitton outlet stores, polo ralph lauren outlet, oakley sunglasses, louis vuitton outlet, christian louboutin shoes, prada handbags, coach factory outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet, burberry outlet, ray ban sunglasses, prada outlet, michael kors outlet, louis vuitton handbags, longchamp outlet, air max, tory burch outlet, coach outlet store online, nike free, kate spade outlet, jordan shoes, louboutin, michael kors outlet, kate spade handbags, michael kors outlet, air max, michael kors outlet, coach purses

1:27 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

oakley sunglasses, michael kors outlet, tiffany and co, burberry outlet, louboutin outlet, louboutin shoes, ray ban sunglasses, michael kors outlet, louis vuitton outlet, oakley sunglasses cheap, coach outlet, chanel handbags, longchamp handbags, louis vuitton, tiffany and co, longchamp handbags, gucci outlet, nike shoes, louis vuitton outlet stores, polo ralph lauren outlet, oakley sunglasses, louis vuitton outlet, christian louboutin shoes, prada handbags, coach factory outlet, polo ralph lauren outlet, burberry outlet, ray ban sunglasses, prada outlet, michael kors outlet, louis vuitton handbags, longchamp outlet, air max, tory burch outlet, coach outlet store online, nike free, kate spade outlet, jordan shoes, louboutin, michael kors outlet, kate spade handbags, michael kors outlet, air max, michael kors outlet, coach purses

1:28 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

polo ralph lauren, sac burberry, lululemon, sac guess, louis vuitton uk, air jordan, ray ban pas cher, nike free pas cher, longchamp, nike roshe run, sac hermes, michael kors pas cher, converse pas cher, vans pas cher, timberland, sac louis vuitton, nike air max, sac louis vuitton, louis vuitton, polo lacoste, ray ban sunglasses, nike blazer, oakley pas cher, air max, louboutin, mulberry, michael kors, north face, true religion outlet, hollister, air force, michael kors, true religion jeans, hollister, air max pas cher, hogan outlet, air max, sac longchamp, new balance pas cher, north face, ralph lauren, true religion jeans, nike tn, vanessa bruno, nike free

1:29 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

polo ralph lauren, sac burberry, lululemon, sac guess, louis vuitton uk, air jordan, ray ban pas cher, nike free pas cher, longchamp, nike roshe run, sac hermes, michael kors pas cher, converse pas cher, vans pas cher, timberland, sac louis vuitton, nike air max, sac louis vuitton, louis vuitton, polo lacoste, ray ban sunglasses, nike blazer, oakley pas cher, air max, louboutin, mulberry, michael kors, north face, true religion outlet, hollister, air force, michael kors, true religion jeans, hollister, air max pas cher, hogan outlet, air max, sac longchamp, new balance pas cher, north face, ralph lauren, true religion jeans, nike tn, vanessa bruno, nike free

1:30 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

ugg, mcm handbags, instyler, insanity workout, ugg australia, reebok outlet, giuseppe zanotti, nfl jerseys, valentino shoes, longchamp, ugg boots, babyliss pro, nike huarache, nike trainers, ghd, hollister, barbour, marc jacobs, north face outlet, bottega veneta, vans shoes, ferragamo shoes, mont blanc, new balance shoes, abercrombie and fitch, ugg pas cher, lululemon outlet, soccer jerseys, p90x, celine handbags, wedding dresses, asics running shoes, birkin bag, abercrombie and fitch, uggs outlet, rolex watches, nike roshe run, soccer shoes, beats by dre, nike roshe, chi flat iron, herve leger, north face jackets, mac cosmetics, jimmy choo outlet

1:30 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

ugg, mcm handbags, instyler, insanity workout, ugg australia, reebok outlet, giuseppe zanotti, nfl jerseys, valentino shoes, longchamp, ugg boots, babyliss pro, nike huarache, nike trainers, ghd, hollister, barbour, marc jacobs, north face outlet, bottega veneta, vans shoes, ferragamo shoes, mont blanc, new balance shoes, abercrombie and fitch, ugg pas cher, lululemon outlet, soccer jerseys, p90x, celine handbags, wedding dresses, asics running shoes, birkin bag, abercrombie and fitch, uggs outlet, rolex watches, nike roshe run, soccer shoes, beats by dre, nike roshe, chi flat iron, herve leger, north face jackets, mac cosmetics, jimmy choo outlet

1:32 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

juicy couture outlet, hollister, air max, louboutin, ralph lauren, canada goose jackets, moncler, vans, juicy couture outlet, moncler, timberland boots, moncler, oakley, canada goose, gucci, ugg, rolex watches, baseball bats, canada goose, air max, canada goose, moncler, canada goose uk, karen millen, hollister clothing store, converse shoes, moncler, wedding dresses, louis vuitton, ugg boots, moncler outlet, parajumpers, canada goose, toms shoes, canada goose outlet, montre homme, moncler, supra shoes, canada goose, converse, hollister, ugg, ray ban, lancel, coach outlet store online, iphone 6 cases

1:33 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

juicy couture outlet, hollister, air max, louboutin, ralph lauren, canada goose jackets, moncler, vans, juicy couture outlet, moncler, timberland boots, moncler, oakley, canada goose, gucci, ugg, rolex watches, baseball bats, canada goose, air max, canada goose, moncler, canada goose uk, karen millen, hollister clothing store, converse shoes, moncler, wedding dresses, louis vuitton, ugg boots, moncler outlet, parajumpers, canada goose, toms shoes, canada goose outlet, montre homme, moncler, supra shoes, canada goose, converse, hollister, ugg, ray ban, lancel, coach outlet store online, iphone 6 cases

1:33 AM

 
Blogger Taibai Li said...

huangqihang0530rolex watches
tory burch outlet
coach outlet online
nike air max
michael kors bag
ray ban sunglasses
kate spade uk
oakley sunglasses
chanel online shop
oakley sunglasses wholesale
ray ban sunglasses
burberry outlet
ray ban outlet
air max 95
true religion outlet
coach outlet store online
coach outlet store online
pandora charms
michael kors outlet online
michael kors
true religion jeans
gucci outlet
oakley sunglass
tory burch outlet online
ray ban glasses
true religion sale
ralph lauren
michael kors
cheap ray ban sunglasses
oakley sunglasses
coach factory outlet
chanel handbags
gucci uk
toms shoes
coach factory outlet
q

6:23 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

jordan shoes, christian louboutin, uggs outlet, michael kors outlet online, uggs on sale, louis vuitton outlet, louis vuitton outlet, louis vuitton, ray ban sunglasses, replica watches, christian louboutin uk, chanel handbags, michael kors outlet online, uggs outlet, longchamp outlet, nike air max, michael kors outlet, burberry handbags, tiffany and co, polo outlet, nike free, nike air max, ugg boots, oakley sunglasses, ray ban sunglasses, michael kors outlet online, oakley sunglasses, christian louboutin outlet, longchamp outlet, prada handbags, gucci handbags, prada outlet, oakley sunglasses wholesale, michael kors outlet, oakley sunglasses, kate spade outlet, christian louboutin shoes, louis vuitton outlet, tory burch outlet, ugg boots, michael kors outlet online, burberry outlet, cheap oakley sunglasses, louis vuitton, ray ban sunglasses, nike outlet, longchamp outlet

6:52 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

sac vanessa bruno, new balance, vans pas cher, ray ban uk, nike blazer pas cher, true religion outlet, michael kors outlet, true religion outlet, replica handbags, polo lacoste, oakley pas cher, coach purses, hollister uk, abercrombie and fitch uk, nike free uk, north face uk, louboutin pas cher, polo ralph lauren, hollister pas cher, nike air max uk, michael kors pas cher, nike air max, true religion jeans, timberland pas cher, nike air max uk, coach outlet, air max, michael kors, jordan pas cher, sac hermes, north face, lululemon canada, coach outlet store online, nike roshe, sac longchamp pas cher, nike air force, mulberry uk, hogan outlet, ralph lauren uk, longchamp pas cher, michael kors, converse pas cher, burberry pas cher, nike roshe run uk, true religion outlet, kate spade, nike free run, nike tn, ray ban pas cher, guess pas cher

6:55 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

asics running shoes, babyliss, soccer jerseys, hermes belt, reebok outlet, ipad cases, oakley, iphone cases, soccer shoes, iphone 5s cases, nfl jerseys, north face outlet, abercrombie and fitch, ghd hair, vans outlet, iphone 6 cases, hollister, nike roshe run, wedding dresses, mac cosmetics, lululemon, new balance shoes, jimmy choo outlet, instyler, giuseppe zanotti outlet, p90x workout, s6 case, chi flat iron, iphone 6s cases, longchamp uk, baseball bats, mcm handbags, iphone 6 plus cases, bottega veneta, ferragamo shoes, timberland boots, mont blanc pens, insanity workout, nike air max, nike trainers uk, herve leger, nike huaraches, celine handbags, north face outlet, beats by dre, iphone 6s plus cases, valentino shoes, ralph lauren, hollister clothing, louboutin

6:58 AM

 
Blogger oakleyses said...

moncler uk, louis vuitton, thomas sabo, wedding dresses, barbour, moncler, gucci, montre pas cher, supra shoes, hollister, barbour uk, nike air max, karen millen uk, pandora uk, moncler, canada goose uk, coach outlet, ugg, juicy couture outlet, swarovski, canada goose, louis vuitton, moncler outlet, louis vuitton, hollister, ugg,ugg australia,ugg italia, canada goose outlet, replica watches, pandora jewelry, ugg,uggs,uggs canada, moncler, canada goose outlet, ugg pas cher, louis vuitton, juicy couture outlet, swarovski crystal, louis vuitton, canada goose, pandora charms, canada goose outlet, links of london, marc jacobs, lancel, converse, converse outlet, toms shoes, doudoune moncler, moncler, pandora jewelry, canada goose jackets, vans, canada goose

7:03 AM

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home